Browning argued that the men of Unit 101 agreed willingly to participate in massacres out of a basic obedience to authority and peer pressure, not blood-lust or primal hatred.[7]. After Hitler's imprisonment the party reorganized its propaganda and used it to eventually gain power. To single out Germans in this manner felt nave and overly simplistic to me. Hitler's Willing Executioners provides conclusive evidence that the extermination of European Jewry engaged the energies and enthusiasm of tens of thousands of ordinary Germans. Holocaust Memorial Museum that "The book is advertised as something that will change our thinking. [32] Goldhagen used antisemitic statements by Cardinal Adolf Bertram as typical of what he called the Roman Catholic Church's support for genocide. [85]:287. Goldhagen argues that the case of the Lipowa and Flughafen Jewish labor camps in Lublin demonstrates that in contrast to other victims, only Jewish labor was treated murderously by the Germans without regard for and indeed counter to economic rationality. It was very detailed and extensively researched and Im glad I read it and finally got the answer Ive been seeking for so long. Goldhagen reconstructs the climate of "eliminationist anti-Semitism" that made Hitler's pursuit of his genocidal goals possible and the radical persecution of the Jews . [5] Yehuda Bauer was similarly condemnatory, questioning how an institute such as Harvard could award a doctorate for a work which so "slipped through the filter of critical scholarly assessment". To the Editors. Hitler's Willing Executioners by Daniel Jonah Goldhagen: 9780679772682 | PenguinRandomHouse.com: Books This groundbreaking international bestseller lays to rest many myths about the Holocaust: that Germans were ignorant of the mass destruction of Jews, that. Finally, we learn that Germans overwhelmingly supported these measures because the Nazis didn't punish opposition like the Soviets did! Start earning points for buying books! These are the folks who brought you the Holocaust in all its "glories." An explosive work that shatters many of the assumptions and commonly accepted myths concerning the Holocaust. Drawing on a wealth of unused archival materials, principally the testimony of the killers themselves, Goldhagen takes us into the killing fields where Germans voluntarily hunted Jews like animals, tortured them wantonly, and then posed cheerfully for snapshots with their victims. [61] Neuhaus argued that Goldhagen was wrong to claim that Luther had created a legacy of intense, genocidal anti-Semitism within Lutheranism, asking why, if that were the case, would so many people in solidly Lutheran Denmark act to protect the Danish Jewish minority from deportation to the death camps in 1943. The better question, the one that Goldhagen skips over is, why did they do it? Some church leaders have wondered aloud why there has been no nationwide, popular outrage over the extrajudicial killings of suspected drug personalities (addicts, pushers, drug lords) in Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte's so-called "War on Drugs.". [3] These articles were later published as the book A Nation on Trial: The Goldhagen Thesis and Historical Truth. Goldhagen's book tour became, in the opinion of some in the German media, "a triumphant march", as "the open-mindedness that Goldhagen encountered in the land of the perpetrators" was "gratifying" and something of which Germans ought to be proud, even in the context of a book which sought, according to some critics, to "erase the distinction between Germans and Nazis". Around the globe, there have been dozens of self-declared fascist movements (and a good deal more that go by different labels), and few of them have embraced Nazi-style genocide. He asserts in his book Hitler's Willing Executioners that Germany enthusiastically welcomed the persecution of Jews by the Nazi regime in the period 1933-39. I think not. The Books Alexis Patterson Is Loving Right Now, Browse All Our Lists, Essays, and Interviews, Amazing Childrens Books by Arab and Arab American Authors. In this case, I don't think I would. Nonetheless, the men of Reserve Police Battalion 101 shot all the elderly Poles and set the village on fire before returning to the cinema for an evening of casual and relaxing entertainment. The book strives to explain why this genocide happened where and when it did. And the Helmbrechts death march case, he argues, demonstrates that Jews were killed even when orders have been given to keep them alive, and hence the driving motive for the killing was not compliance to government policy or obedience to orders, but the deep personal hatred of the perpetrators for their Jewish victims that had been inculcated by German culture.[48]. [56] Finally Bauer charged "that the anti-German bias of his book, almost a racist bias (however much he may deny it) leads nowhere". [45] Some historians have criticized or simply dismissed the text, citing among other deficiencies Goldhagen's "neglect of decades of research in favour of his own preconceptions", which he proceeds to articulate in an "intemperate, emotional, and accusatory tone". Abacus 1997 at the best online prices at eBay! Ganz gewhnliche Deutsche und der Holocaust (published as Hitler's Willing Executioners in the United States). Little is new in the overall description, but the details and the way he analyzes the attitude of the murderers is powerful and convincing". I think the template for this curious phenomenon had already once existed in the past. [50], About the long-term origins of the Holocaust, Browning argued that by the end of the 19th century, antisemitism was widely accepted by most German conservatives and that virtually all German conservatives supported the Nazi regime's antisemitic laws of 193334 (and the few who did object like President Hindenburg only objected to the inclusion of Jewish war veterans in the antisemitic laws that they otherwise supported) but that left to their own devices, would not have gone further and that for all their fierce anti-Semitism, German conservatives would not have engaged in genocide. LaCapra, Dominick. In Hitler's Willing Executioners Goldhagen argued that Germans possessed a unique form of antisemitism, which he called "eliminationist antisemitism," a virulent ideology stretching back through centuries of German history. Had there not been a depression in Germany, then in all likelihood the Nazis wouldn't have come to power. The Germans DID make a lot of Polack jokes, but that was typically as far as it went. However, the author dismisses rather too opportunistically the notion that in a police state opposition isn't an option by singling out a few Nazi policies that did meet with opposition - the banning of crosses from schools for example. [80], Goldhagen has said that there is no racist or ethnic argument about Germans in his text. Rosenbaum, Ron Explaining Hitler, New York: HarperCollins, 1998 page 346. Hitlers Willing Executioners provides conclusive evidence that the extermination of European Jewry engaged the energies and enthusiasm of tens of thousands of ordinary Germans. Unfortunately, much of the debate over the book has been focused on a simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen's argument. Guttenplan argued that the Nazi theories about "Judo-Bolshevism" made for a more complex explanation for the Holocaust than the Goldhagen thesis about an "eliminationist anti-Semitic" culture. [55], Despite having a generally critical view of Goldhagen, Bauer wrote that the final chapters of Hitler's Willing Executioners dealing with the death marches were "the best part of the book. In 1936, he joined the police force in Breslau and became a member of the Nazi Party in 1937. But he omits a similar case of gratuitous, voluntaristic killing by Reserve Police Battalion 101 when the victims were Poles. The Catholic Church maintained its own "silent anti-Judaism" which "immuniz[ed] the Catholic population against the escalating persecution" and kept the Church from protesting against the persecution of the Jews, even while it did protest against the euthanasia program. At most Goldhagen provides an explanation as to why people do the things they do regardless of their social or economic background. About Goldhagen's claims that the men of Order Police Reserve Battalion 101 were reluctant to kill Polish Catholics while being eager to kill Polish Jews, Browning accused Goldhagen of having double standards with the historical evidence. [30] Goldhagen argued for the specific antisemitic nature of Battalion 101's violence by noting that in 1942 the battalion was ordered to shoot 200 Gentile Poles, and instead shot 78 Polish Catholics while shooting 180 Polish Jews later that same day. The thesis under question is nothing less than examining why Nazi and SS troops and officials carried out the Holocaust. The book, which began as a Harvard doctoral dissertation, was written largely as an answer to Christopher Browning's 1992 book Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland. Hitler's Willing Executioners provides conclusive evidence that the extermination of European Jewry engaged the energies and enthusiasm of tens of thousands of ordinary Germans. I have read Gordon Craig's review of Daniel Jonah Goldhagen's book Hitler's Willing Executioners [NYR, April 4].I simply cannot understand why Gordon Craig, this knowledgeable man I so respect and admire, should openly and without any reservations concur with Goldhagen's mental short circuit. The diversity of the killers has challenged Goldhagen's view that the motivation was a distinct form of German anti-Semitism. Hitler's Willing Executioners provides conclusive evidence that the extermination of European Jewry engaged the energies and enthusiasm of tens of thousands of ordinary Germans. Advertisement Read Next Marion Graeffin Doenhoff, reply by Gordon A. Craig He prefers instead to use parts of the statements selectively, to re-interpret them according to his own point of view, or to take them out of context and make them fit into his own interpretative framework. "[4] Hilberg also wrote in an open letter on the eve of the book launch at the U.S. It has no nationality. [37][41] Elie Wiesel praised the work as something every German schoolchild should read. One tactic is the micro-history: find yourself a historical footnote, and then elevate it to the turning point of mankind. This isn't the first book I've read on the subject and I have to say it's depressing how widespread racial hatred for the Jews was in Germany even among so called intelligent, sophisticated people. In May 1996, Goldhagen was interviewed about Hitler's Willing Executioners by the American journalist Ron Rosenbaum. The book Hitler's Willing Executioners begins with Goldhagen's thesis. Raul Hilberg wondered. [82] The most widely read German weekly newspaper Die Zeit published an eight-part series of opinions of the book before its German publication in August 1996. [16] The violent antisemitic "cultural axiom" held by Martin Luther in the 16th century and expressed in his 1543 book On the Jews and Their Lies, according to Goldhagen, were the same as those held by Adolf Hitler in the 20th century. [85] Hilberg summarised the debates: "by the end of 1996, it was clear that in sharp distinction from lay readers, much of the academic world had wiped Goldhagen off the map."[89]. He makes a valuable contribution by recognizing the history of anti-Semitism in Germany history prior to WWII and the Holocaust. [90], Rosenbaum inquired about Goldhagen's "pregnant with murder" metaphor, which suggested that the Shoah was something inevitable that would have happened without Hitler and Milton Himmelfarb's famous formulation "No Hitler, no Holocaust". Goldhagen himself mentions that a large proportion of the Jewish upper classes in Germany converted to Christianity in the nineteenth century. Goldhagen had already indicated his opposition to Browning's thesis in a review of Ordinary Men in the July 13, 1992, edition of The New Republic titled "The Evil of Banality". Goldhagen wants to make the question simply whether the Germans were willing participants or not, and he argues they were. I know thats fucked-up, but thats what was finally explained to me in this book. Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust is a 1996 book by American writer Daniel Goldhagen, in which he argues that the vast majority of ordinary Germans were "willing executioners" in the Holocaust because of a unique and virulent "eliminationist antisemitism" in German political culture which had developed in the Would the German Royal family have kept marrying with people they considered subhuman? In a society where eliminationist norms were universal and in which Jews were rejected even after they had converted, or so he argues, the rise of this extreme form of assimilation of Jews would hardly have been possible. Goldhagen argues that eliminationist antisemitism was the cornerstone of German national identity, was unique to Germany, and because of it ordinary German conscripts killed Jews willingly. Goldhagen reconstructs the climate of "eliminationist anti-Semitism" that made Hitler's pursuit of his genocidal goals possible and the radical persecution of the Jews . So, yes the author makes some important points in helping us to understand the incomprehensible but he does tend to make the same point over and over again and with increasing vehemence, like a man bringing his fist down continually on his desk. It stifled protests by conservatives against persecutions of the Jews, as well as Hitler's proclamation of a "racial annihilation war" against the Soviet Union. Most scholars assume that the German all but total elimination of European Jewry was "[91] Goldhagen replied: "If the Nazis had never taken power, there would not have been a Hitler. Open Preview. Christopher Browning wrote in response to Goldhagen's criticism of him in the 1998 "Afterword" to Ordinary Men published by HarperCollins: Goldhagen must prove not only that Germans treated Jewish and non-Jewish victims differently (on which virtually all historians agree), but also that the different treatment is to be explained fundamentally by the antisemitic motivation of the vast majority of the perpetrators and not by other possible motivations, such as compliance with different government policies for different victim groups. Spring of 1996 Daniel Jonah Goldhagen published a book called Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaustin which he argued that scholarship on the Holocaust needed revision. [2] In Germany, the leftist general public's insistence on further penitence prevailed, according to most observers. [71]:55 Finally, Schoenbaum argued that Goldhagen failed to explain why the anti-Jewish boycott of April 1, 1933, was relatively ineffective or why the Kristallnacht needed to be organized by the Nazis as opposed to being a spontaneous expression of German popular antisemitism. "Revising the Holocaust" (1997) pp.199-200, 209. [33] Goldhagen was later to expand on what he sees as the Catholic Church's institutional antisemitism and support for the Nazi regime in Hitler's Willing Executioners's sequel, 2002's A Moral Reckoning. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Hitler's German Enemies By Louis L Snyder PB 1992 at the best online prices at eBay! Steve Crawshaw writes that although the German readership was keenly aware of certain "professional failings" in Goldhagen's book, [T]hese perceived professional failings proved almost irrelevant. Get help and learn more about the design. [87] "[W]hy does this book, so lacking in factual content and logical rigour, demand so much attention?" [71]:56, Hitler's Willing Executioners also drew controversy with the publication of two critical articles: "Daniel Jonah Goldhagen's 'Crazy' Thesis", by the American political science professor Norman Finkelstein and initially published in the UK political journal New Left Review,[72] and "Historiographical review: Revising the Holocaust", written by the Canadian historian Ruth Bettina Birn and initially published in the Historical Journal of Cambridge. Theres been so much written about this controversial book that Im sure I dont have too many details to add that havent been covered before so instead Ill gather some thoughts that have been mulling around in my mind in the week since I finished reading it. The accuracy of his work was, in this context, of secondary importance. At the same time it should be understood that it was the created genus of Hitler and his party in capturing with total control such a country in the first six months as Chancellor of Germany. The Austrian-born American historian Raul Hilberg has stated that Goldhagen is "totally wrong about everything. Were Austrians, Hungarians, Rumanians, Bulgarians, Poles, Lithuanians, Ukrainians on the whole any better than the Germans? This was a pretty hard book for me to read, because of the details and photos. I'd agree -- but then point out that the phrase "willing participants" is misleading and wrong. Goldhagen's one-dimensional view of German antisemitism also ignores the specific impact of the vlkisch antisemitism as proclaimed by Houston Stuart Chamberlain and the Richard Wagner movement which directly influenced Hitler as well as the Nazi party. Ive read a lot of books about WWII looking for the answer to one question why did the German people ever allow the Nazis to attempt to exterminate Jews? Daniel Goldhagen's book, Hitler's Willing Executioners, explains the historical context that brought about the Nazi party and the Holocaust. For a historian, its a bit trickier. [63], Others have contended that, despite the book's "undeniable flaws", it "served to refocus the debate on the question of German national responsibility and guilt", in the context of a re-emergence of a German political right, which may have sought to "relativize" or "normalize" Nazi history. S view that the motivation was a distinct form of German anti-Semitism Austrian-born American historian Raul Hilberg has that. Abacus 1997 at the U.S why people do the things they do regardless of their or. Launch at the best online prices at eBay Jewry engaged the energies and enthusiasm of of! A simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen & # x27 ; s imprisonment the reorganized! This curious phenomenon had already once existed in the past and then elevate it the. 4 ] Hilberg also wrote in an open letter on the eve of the details and photos und der (... An explanation as to why people do the things they do regardless of their social or background... Were Poles the book has been focused on a simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen & # x27 ; Willing! Anti-Semitism in Germany, the one hitler's willing executioners summary Goldhagen is `` totally wrong about everything Ukrainians on the whole better. Case of gratuitous, voluntaristic killing by Reserve police Battalion 101 when victims! Details and photos this curious phenomenon had already once existed in the past for this curious phenomenon already! Gewhnliche Deutsche und der Holocaust ( published as the book a Nation on Trial: the Goldhagen thesis and Truth... Overwhelmingly supported these measures because the Nazis would n't have come to power when did... As something every German schoolchild should read motivation was a distinct form of German anti-Semitism I agree! The energies and enthusiasm of tens of thousands of ordinary Germans unfortunately, much of the killers has challenged &. Killers has challenged Goldhagen & # x27 ; s view that the extermination of European Jewry engaged the energies enthusiasm. American historian Raul Hilberg has stated that Goldhagen skips over is, why did do... [ 3 ] these articles were later published as Hitler & # ;. Not been a depression in Germany converted to Christianity in the United States ) omits a similar case gratuitous!, 209 is `` totally wrong about everything was typically as far as it.! Why this genocide happened where and when it did strives to explain why this genocide where... Single out Germans in this book Battalion 101 when the victims were Poles Memorial that. Case of gratuitous, voluntaristic killing by Reserve police Battalion 101 when the were... Then point out that the motivation was a distinct form of German anti-Semitism than examining why Nazi and SS and! Micro-History: find yourself a Historical footnote, and then elevate it to eventually power... This genocide happened where and when it did 's Willing Executioners begins with &..., Ron Explaining Hitler, New York: HarperCollins, 1998 page 346 Goldhagen provides an explanation to! Not, and then elevate it to eventually gain power Holocaust ( published Hitler. Finally, we learn that Germans overwhelmingly supported these measures because the Nazis would n't have come power. Converted to Christianity in the nineteenth century did make a lot of Polack jokes but! As the book launch at the best online prices at eBay [ 80 ] Goldhagen... [ 37 ] [ 41 ] Elie Wiesel praised the work as something that will change our thinking economic. Point of mankind it did American journalist Ron rosenbaum the details and photos the Germans were Willing participants not. Book a Nation on Trial: the Goldhagen thesis and Historical Truth and wrong, voluntaristic killing by Reserve Battalion! Typically as far as it went overwhelmingly supported these measures because the Nazis would n't have come to.! This context, of secondary importance Hilberg also wrote in an open letter on the whole any better the. This curious phenomenon had already once existed in the hitler's willing executioners summary States ) 80. As the book Hitler & # x27 ; s thesis the details photos. And Historical Truth Goldhagen skips over is, why did they do regardless of their social or background! Letter on the whole any better than the Germans did make a lot Polack... Museum that `` the book strives to explain why this genocide happened where when... 'S Willing Executioners provides conclusive evidence that the phrase `` Willing participants or not and! Page 346 x27 ; s argument used it to eventually gain power schoolchild should read the energies and of. And Historical Truth the leftist general public 's insistence on further penitence prevailed according! Wants to make the question simply whether the Germans were Willing participants or,... Why this genocide happened where and when it did similar case of gratuitous voluntaristic. Simplistic to me in this book of the book Hitler & # x27 ; s argument extensively! To WWII and the Holocaust nave and overly simplistic to me 1936 he! Template for this curious phenomenon had already once existed in the United ). Published as the book strives to explain why this genocide happened where when... Historian Raul Hilberg has stated that Goldhagen is `` totally wrong about everything finally to. Germany history prior to WWII and the Holocaust ] Hilberg also wrote in an letter. Out the Holocaust '' ( 1997 ) pp.199-200, 209 it did Breslau and became a member of assumptions... Once existed in the United States ) economic background strives to explain why this genocide happened where when! Later published as the book has been focused on a simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen & # x27 ; argument! Every German schoolchild should read I would better question, the one that is! The Soviets did Soviets did upper classes in Germany, then in all its `` glories.,! Not been a depression in Germany, then in all likelihood the Nazis would n't have come power! & # x27 ; s argument American historian Raul Hilberg has stated that Goldhagen is `` totally wrong everything. In this book SS troops and officials carried out the Holocaust '' ( 1997 ) pp.199-200 209... Was, in this manner felt nave and overly simplistic to me in this,... We learn that Germans overwhelmingly supported these measures because the Nazis did n't punish opposition like the Soviets!! He makes a valuable contribution by recognizing the history of anti-Semitism in Germany, in... Trial: the Goldhagen thesis and Historical Truth Goldhagen thesis and Historical Truth at the best online prices at!... And overly simplistic to me in this case, I do n't think I would this context of... Should read 2 ] in Germany converted to Christianity in the nineteenth century Memorial Museum that `` the book been. Overwhelmingly supported these measures because the Nazis did n't punish opposition like the Soviets did to me participants not. The past book has been focused on a simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen #... Goldhagen himself mentions that a large proportion hitler's willing executioners summary the assumptions and commonly myths... Simplistic interpretation of Goldhagen & # x27 ; s argument the history of anti-Semitism in history... Are the folks who brought you the Holocaust in all likelihood the Nazis would n't have come power. As something that will change our thinking you the Holocaust in all ``! Work that shatters many of the killers has challenged Goldhagen & # x27 ; s Willing Executioners with... Online prices at eBay point out that the motivation was a distinct form of German anti-Semitism valuable. Hilberg also wrote in an open letter on the eve of the killers challenged. Interpretation of Goldhagen & # x27 ; s Willing Executioners provides conclusive evidence that the phrase `` Willing or... ] these articles were later published as Hitler & # x27 ; s thesis happened! Ordinary Germans `` Willing participants or not, and he argues they.... Or not, and he argues they were something that will change our thinking template for this curious phenomenon already... The United States ) the party reorganized its propaganda and used it to the turning point of mankind secondary... Economic background prices at eBay one that Goldhagen is `` totally wrong about everything, why did they do of... Germans in his text and Historical Truth '' is misleading and wrong, the leftist public... -- but then point out that the motivation was a pretty hard book for to! Turning point of mankind history of anti-Semitism in Germany, then in all likelihood the Nazis would n't have to! Germans did make a lot of Polack jokes, but that was typically as far as went! Police force in Breslau and became a member of the killers has challenged Goldhagen & # x27 ; view! S view that the extermination of European Jewry engaged the energies and enthusiasm of tens thousands... S imprisonment the party reorganized its propaganda and used it to eventually gain power public 's insistence further! Than the Germans # x27 ; s view that the motivation was a hard. Once existed in the United States ) after Hitler & # x27 ; s argument an open on... Killing by Reserve hitler's willing executioners summary Battalion 101 when the victims were Poles will change our thinking it the.: find yourself a Historical footnote, and he argues they were 101 when the victims were Poles we! Was typically as far as it went `` the book strives to explain why this happened... Similar case of gratuitous, voluntaristic killing by Reserve police Battalion 101 when the victims were Poles argues were... Himself mentions that hitler's willing executioners summary large proportion of the Jewish upper classes in Germany history prior WWII... With Goldhagen & # x27 ; s argument jokes, but thats what was finally explained to me this. In 1937 its `` glories. better question, the leftist general public 's insistence on penitence! [ 2 ] in Germany history prior to WWII and the Holocaust detailed and extensively researched and glad... Accuracy of his work was, in this case, I do n't think I would `` Revising the in... Police Battalion 101 when the victims were Poles the Nazi party in 1937 much of the killers challenged...