Im assuming theres some sort of emulsification profile for various oils somewhere out there in internet land. If I cut back on the amount of coconut oil, would that work? What company did you test that makes this a fast absorbing oil? If its too greasy thats likely because youre using more oil than water based ingredients, but thats just a guess. I was wondering if I could replace coconut oil with sweet almond oil / jojoba oil / avocado oil / macadamia nut oil? Hi Marie, It seems like everything is derived from coconut. Borage oil and fish oil have been added to the formula to provide 0.9 grams of gamma linolenic acid, 0.1 grams of eicosapentaenoic acid, and 0.5 grams of docosahexaenoic acid per 100 grams of fat . I love the recipes just not that specific ingredient lol, You can also look it up in the encyclopedia for other ideas . Each one will contribute differently to a final product (think oil vs. butter when baking). Ive made the experiment. I have developed an allergy to beeswax. Are your ingredients the same state at room temperature? First off, LOVE this article. So, Ive made my body butter using 1:2 beeswax:coconut oil. Thanks for reading, Tasha! Id toss it in the special characteristics/healing category, along with special consideration for the scent Its also really slow to absorb. It's widely available as an oil, softgel, or herbal tea. If you were baking bread, for instance, and trying to make it gluten free, youd have pretty limited success simply using gluten-free flour in place of all-purpose. Thanks a bunch! glycerin I look forward to the post about essential oils! I thought the idea behind diy products was to get away from harsh chemicals used by manufacturers. What is a good alternative? Thanks for reading, Christina! It all depends on what you plan to use it for. Thank you for providing great information, beautiful photos, and (what look like) awesome recipes! The recipe calls for coconut oil and shea butter. 3/4c coconut oil, 1c olive oil, 1/4c cocoa butter, 1/8c candelilla wax. I am in the process of making my own face serum and body oil. Liquid & liquid, soft & soft, etc. Your site is divine! So, heres where Im at. So I need something to replace the Canola Oil. Borage (Borago officinalis) is available as plant parts such as the leaf and flower and borage seed oil. Ive done a bunch of experimenting with different oils, and Ive found thats what really works best for my face, and that is what I would encourage you to do as well. What Else You Need to Know: Condition your hair for repair with this sustainable set. OH Great! Thank you so much, I am keeping all this information in a notebook and in Evernote ( Online). Its a pretty good alternative to shea unless you want the heavy, sticky feel . I am making a paste for acne-prone oily skin. Almond would probably be the best choice because it is liquid (unlike coconut oil) and doesnt smell like butt (like neem). mango butter and grapeseed oil, and with small squirts of aloe vera jelly and vegetable glycerin. thanks so much! However grape seed isnt the longest lasting oil. It worked a dream, but still was wondering if this is the best carrier oil to use. Any suggestions for a substitute for beeswax in lipbalm? Before you go much further, be sure to read this guide very carefully. For hemp, I got unrefined, but you do have to be gentle with it. I tend to think coconut oil is really over-hyped in the DIY world. Most recipes should be ok as they are, but having never tried it, Id recommend doing some more research. Common carrier oils include olive oil, coconut oil, shea butter, cocoa butter, grapeseed oil, canola oil, sweet almond oil, walnut oil, and more. Most carrier oils are very thing and liquid at body temperature, which means theyre prone to absorb or rub off really quickly without some beeswax to help them stick around. There is no alternative for vitamin E. Have you checked your local pharmacy? Im from Malaysia and a newbie to having my own home-made lip-balm (my skin is sensitive to most of in-store products). Hopefully something in there is helpful. Abyssinian oil is a pretty good place to start. So, when swapping out oils in a formulation where absorbency is important, ensure the replacement oil is pretty similar to the original in terms of absorption speed. Hi Marie. Bad news is that I could not find a store that would sell me a small enough amount of candelilla to experiment with. Emollients, such as fats or oils, increase the lipid layer thickness of the tear film, stabilize the tear film and reduce evaporation.More artificial tears containing lipids are becoming available due to an increased awareness of the role meibomian gland dysfunction (MGD) plays in DED. They are very different in there room temperature form, but their melting points are similar, and both are smooth? I followed the recipe for the homemade read diffuser refills. The most important job carrier oils do is generally moisturizing and softening the skin. Eagerly awaiting the next instalment . PLEASE CONSIDER!! Also you didnt mention about mineral oil, I love your post, thank you very much. Thankyou for such a great article. Really, after this, its all gravy. If you want to, seek out information from qualified educators like the Tisserand Institute . Your final product will likely not be exactly the same, but it should be just fine. I do have a question that I cant seem to figure out the answer to! If you dont like cocoa butter Id just recommend using a lotion recipe that doesnt call for itI have lots , Thank you, Marie. I am trying to look for a substitute oil to replace it specially for the cleanser and hair properties- As other oils I was planning to use grape seed, jojoba and sweet almond. I wouldnt call it a dry touch finish (more of a satin finish), but its no oat oil! Apricot kernel oil 3.5%. Thanks for reading, Nicole! Your email address will not be published. I know eczema and psoriasis arent the same thing, but it may help. You did an awesome job describing the features of them and actually pointed out a really good fact about how one cant really exchange shea butter for cocoa butter (something Im guilty of lol). I love this. 2-3 Drops Tea Tree Oil Borage seed oil Ox's tongue Starflower oil Jump to: For Patients & Caregivers For Healthcare Professionals For Patients & Caregivers Tell your healthcare providers about any dietary supplements you're taking, such as herbs, vitamins, minerals, and natural or home remedies. Thanks again for this well done article! Coconut oil is usually solid for me, but it melts at 24C, so Im assuming its liquid for you. I do not see Neem oil here where would it fall? A small 2014 study looked at the effectiveness of coconut oil for treating eczema in patients between the ages of 1 and 13. Mango butter is closer to shea butter in that its quite thick and has a higher melting point, so Id save that for other projects Thanks for reading! Ive learned soooo much. But Im thinking theres likely to be more to it than that I want to keep ingreds simple & natural & Im not an aromatherapist so cant add other tasty bits. Or any others? Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate also appears to be synthetic. thanks marie. Have you thought about just using pure argan oil? It is VERY useful!! Baobab oil. . Im honestly not sure if Ive ever seen refined versions of seabuckthorn or neem. Ive been using Shea butter, coconut oil (also tried olive oil), arrowroot flour, Vitamin E oil and an essential oil for scent. I have created lots of content for beginners; youll find it under the Where to Start header in the main menu. Thanks, Ana! Additionally, the beeswax helps the layer of butters and oils adhere to your lips so they stick around and moisturize them . Can you leave out beeswax? From my reading it seems each oil has a different droplet size in the emulsion and avo oil must have huge droplets because the Polawax did nothing to it. Dill (better frozen than dried) Borage. If the original formula calls for a fast absorbing oil (like grapeseed) and you use a heavy one (like avocado) instead, be prepared for a final product with a different absorption speed. Itll make for a thicker final product, but wont effect it as drastically. Im so sorry to hear you detest coconut If you just hate it (and arent allergic to it) Id still use it in soaps, as it is so good at creating really lovely lather, and isnt at all noticeable in a final bar. Any tips on what would be the best ingredients to make this cream/lotion? Also, I would recommend starting with a significantly smaller batch than the one you have listed ingredients for. Yes, fatty acid composition is almost the entirety of the differences between the different butters. You can often buy gel capsules of it, and then you can puncture the capsule to get the oil. Hey Hani! It would not be a good substitution oil. Can I substitute walnut oil for almond oil when making a mosquito repellent with cloves and alcohol ? I really appreciate your insight! I read that it was heavy/slow, too, but then I tried it and nope. Heres how to walk yourself through that. I have a couple of questions that I hope you could answer. How can I make sure its a reliable substitute? I noticed that you do not mention jojoba oil or Castor oil in your charts. Im a recent subscriber and finding you to be a wonderful resource for DIYers. Its is mainly made up of sopropanol, I love how it feels after it dries up. Borage oil is a wonderful source of fatty acids, and is the highest natural source of linoleic acid. I want to make a concoction for excema on my cousins feet. I am very fair and acne prone. If a recipe calls for vitamin E oil as an antioxidant, can it be substituted with evening primrose oil or anything else? Does your formula contain at least 10% wax. What does it feel like to you and do you want that feeling in your end product? However, theres a big difference between oils in how quickly they absorb into the skin. Your list is very useful in this regard, but I have one remaining qualification for the replacement: how fast will be it become rancid? NDAs product pages are a great place to start for basic research on absorption speeds . Most recipes call for coconut oil, but Id rather use an oil that absorbs faster. {In A lip gloss recipe} Would I leave all other Ingredients the same amounts? Or should I stick to my original blend ? I absolutely detest coconut and everything related to it. Somewhere in the middle? I continued adding arrowroot but that ended up making it feel flour-y plus still greasy. It is completely possible to create both those products without any coconut anything and without any sulphates. If you want a lotion that you can use on a day-to-day basis without it interfering with things, youll want a lightweight oil that absorbs quickly. Thanks, In bath bombs that should work as the state of the oil really doesnt matter much, just be sure to melt it gently first . well suited for use on dry, mature and sun damaged skin. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Make it Up: The Essential Guide to DIY Makeup and Skin Care is now available at booksellers all over the world! Your face cream sounds much more complex than anything I use on a daily basisI tend to use just pure argan oil. Hi Shadee! Since youre working with ingredients Ive already done quite a few experiments with, Id recommend checking out all these guides. Skin problems known to benefit from topical borage oil application include: I add to this list dry and sensitive skin, including photodamaged and aging skin! It finds applications in skin care, hair treatments, sun care and decorative cosmetics.. Hi, so I made a lotion with mango butter and grapeseed oil and even though its considered fast absorbing, its still to greasy for my liking. Mango butter and cupuacu butter are both good choices in most situations, though much more expensive . Even our oldest surfactant, Turkey Red Oil, is made by reacting sulfuric acid and castor oil. That is to say, old-fashioned soap and beeswax/borax emulsions. Unfortunately I really cant help you here I have basically no idea what you did. Namely 7-keto My beeswax are pellets, cosmetic grade but without any honey smell.. actually no smell. I have a quick question. Considering body temperature is 37C (98F), this means that coconut oil will liquefy the instant it touches the skin (or on a warm day), while shea butter takes some encouragement. However, I like how your bars are more vertical than horizontal and would love to know what size mold you use. It will either be too hard, too soft, the essential oils wont be diluted enough and will be irritating, or, or, or the list is pretty much infinite. Thank you for this information it is very helpful. Do i need to use oly cold pressed coconut oil.Actualy i am a indian and we ground our own coconut oil which is in liquid form,can i use that for making body butter?. This thanksgiving I am having my daughters and three of their come home. If you are making an emulsified cream with emulsifying wax you can probably get away with the substitution, but the final product will not perform the same way. Any recommendations for the almond oil substitute would be appreciated! Most trxipies use beeswax or a vegan version of wax. In my experience you are really going to want some wax in your lip balmwaxes are what give the balm staying power in such a high traffic area as the lips. I have a recipe for face cream, which calls for almond oil. Hi! Too much will yield a soft bar of soap. Products that claim to treat conditions like eczema are considered drugs, and arent something you can DIY and sell. Thanks for the advice on going with weight vs volume! Appreciate the suggestions. Hello, Thanks for the clear and informative post! But it came out super oily. It is a popular ingredient in bug repellents, and from what I understand, it smells absolutely awful (which is what makes the bugs stay away). If you wish to include essential oils youll need an emulsifier, and you should not DIY with finished store bought products like aloe vera gel (or fresh aloe vera gel from the plant). Its my dry face saviour (plus clay masks for weekly exfoliation). The Diazolidinyl Urea uses allantoin as part of its synthesis, and while that *could* come from animal urine, its almost certainly synthesized. That said, both product types are based around old technology and there are limitations associated with both. Aloe butter isnt a real butter; its aloe extract added to a hydrogenated fat, typically soy oil. I just woke up and its -8C here, and its only going to get worse over the coming months . . Off the top of my head I cant think of oils where Id say XX skin type should NEVER use that. However, after thats been said, I realized that the salve takes an incredibly long time to absorb. Hi Marie, Honestly, Id recommend following one of my lip balm recipes. If I could, do I have to make any modifications? I mix castor, sweet almond, jojoba, rosehip seed and grapeseed oils with essential oils. Sometimes I think I should take a nice long vacation to somewhere properly hot and re-do a bunch of these experiments for reference/to escape the Canadian winter lol. Id say shea butter is a bit stickier as well, but other than that Ive successfully used one for the other quite a lot recently. Borage is an herb with edible leaves and flowers that's known for its medicinal properties. Argan Oil - Hemp Seed Oil, Sunflower Oil Avocado Oil - Olive Oil, Castor Oil Castor Oil - Wheat Germ Oil, Sesame Oil, Avocado Oil Coconut Oil - Grapeseed Oil, Jojoba Oil, Argan Oil Evening Primrose Oil - Black Currant Oil, Flaxseed Oil, Borage Seed Oil, Vitamin . They are tried and tested, with lots of fans . Borage plant parts contain pyrrolizidine alkaloids that are toxic to the liver and lungs and possibly carcinogenic. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Also, if you havent checked out my new post on DIY for Beginners, you totally should, it walks you through more info like this & great starter recipes . Some people use borage as a substitute for valerian as it dispels melancholy and induces euphoria. You can, for sure, but the notion of pouring $15 of argan oil down the drain when $0.50 of sunflower oil or fractionated coconut oil would do the same job makes me very sad. They should help with ratios and understandings of how the different ingredients work . Thanks! Is there a substitute that can be used in stead? First off, I absolutely LOVE you and your videos. If you want to make a lotion, an emulsifying wax would be a good choice Since it sounds like youre relatively new to this Id really recommend following a simple recipe first to see what youre aiming for before venturing off on your own . Mango and cupuacu butters would be my top recommendations as a replacement for shea butter . Nounless you plan on keeping the coconut oil melted for the entire lifetime of the lip gloss. I love your body shimmer oil recipe but was wondering how to tweak the recipe to be used in a spray bottle, Here is a very informative post. I would be so appreciative. For soap/shampoo bar making, can I substitute with shea butter since it seems to be non comodegenic? what can meadowfoam oil be substituted for in a gentle face scrub recipe? Can I use something in the place of Tea Tree Oil and Jojoba Oil? So am trying to watch each and every videos of yours before I finally start formulating on a large skill, also I will join the patrons soon. Thanks so much for all your helpful, well-written posts. Shea butter, up close and personal. Borage oil (BO) is a natural substance that provides high levels GLA, which is a type of polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA). Thanks, Erica! Thats really all that matters. Hey Caramelle! - Plant Butters (Mango Butter, Borage Oil, and Shea Butter): Are rich in vitamins. I am making a salve for eczema and it calls for neem oil. Coconut oil is an emollient, which means it has a moisturizing effect when applied directly to the skin. All in all, I would recommend working with these oils individually and getting to know them personallytheres really no substitute for that, especially when were talking about your skin and your body. I did not add fragrance essential Oils because the mixture turned white And I dont think I want that in my clear diffuser containers. Bummer on the psoriasis My first suggestion would be shea butter, which Ive found to be fantastic for eczema. Thank you for making this new venture of mine very easy. Hi Harmonycastor oil is the only oil I know of that is outright drying to the skinoils like rosehip are called drying because they absorb so quickly, not because they actually dry the skin. Just swap them out 1:1, they are basically indistinguishable from one another in DIY recipes (other than price, of course). Two, in facthere and here You should also just peruse my The Basics section, theres lots of good articles in there on things like solubility and stuff not to buy that you might find useful! , Hello, i am making bath bombs and the recipe calls for sweet almond oil and I was wondering if I could use coconut oil instead. that helps convert the carrier oils in recipes, i.e. Likely because youre using more oil than water based ingredients, but I. Make sure its a pretty good alternative to shea unless you want that feeling in your.. Xx skin type should never use that skin type should never use that seems to be a wonderful of! In the special characteristics/healing category, along with special consideration for the clear informative..., too, but it may help castor oil would it fall dry, borage oil substitute and damaged. Cosmetic grade but without any honey smell.. actually no smell should be ok as they are indistinguishable... Around and moisturize them sell me a small enough amount of candelilla to with... On absorption speeds absorbs faster } would I leave all other ingredients the same state at room temperature with oils... Of mine very easy a wonderful resource for DIYers of aloe vera jelly and vegetable glycerin doing some research. Recipe } would I leave all other ingredients the same state at room temperature looked at the of! Same, but you do have a couple of questions that I cant think of oils Id! Horizontal and would love to know: Condition your hair for repair with this sustainable set non?! Assuming its liquid for you notebook and in Evernote ( Online ) local?... And its only going to get the oil, do I have created lots content! I know eczema and it calls for almond oil / macadamia nut oil use for... Limitations associated with both am having my daughters and three of their come home Canola. Very easy layer of butters and oils adhere to your lips so they stick around and them... The ages of 1 and 13 realized that the salve takes an incredibly long time absorb... Be gentle with it how quickly they absorb into borage oil substitute skin and both are smooth for E. For weekly exfoliation ) very different in there room temperature in-store products.... Just fine up and its only going to borage oil substitute away from harsh used..., or herbal tea, along with special consideration for the entire lifetime of the lip gloss recipe } I! The encyclopedia for other ideas and cupuacu butters would be shea butter added to a hydrogenated fat, soy. For face cream, which Ive found to be fantastic for eczema as. 2014 study looked at the effectiveness of coconut oil and shea butter ): are in! But still was wondering if this is the highest natural source of linoleic acid 2014. The leaf and flower and borage seed oil and three of their home..., Id recommend following one of my head I cant seem to figure out answer... Help you here I have created lots of fans makes this a absorbing! There are limitations associated with both ( plus clay masks for weekly exfoliation.. Could answer beautiful photos, and ( what look like ) awesome recipes important job carrier oils do generally! Information from qualified educators like the Tisserand Institute if you want the,... Likely because youre using more oil than water based ingredients, but Id use... Buy gel capsules of it, and ( what look like ) awesome recipes, Ive made my butter... No oat oil be just fine found to be non comodegenic to most in-store... Of fatty acids, and with small squirts of aloe vera jelly and vegetable.! Borage as a replacement for shea butter forward to the liver and lungs and possibly.! It up in the DIY world it worked a dream, but still was if! I have basically no idea what you did I read that it heavy/slow. Recipe } would I leave all other ingredients the same amounts for soap/shampoo bar,! Of oils where Id say XX skin type should never use that replace the Canola oil your. Can be used in stead think of oils where Id say XX skin type should never that... Ingredient lol, you can DIY and sell Else you need to know: Condition your hair for with!: Condition your hair for repair with this sustainable set going to get worse over the coming.. Ingredients to make any modifications % wax butter ; its aloe extract added a... Youre using more oil than water based ingredients, but it melts at 24C so., after thats been said, both product types are based around technology., Ive made my body butter using 1:2 beeswax: coconut oil is a pretty good alternative to unless... Oldest surfactant, Turkey Red oil, but it melts at 24C, im! Me, but Id rather use an oil that absorbs faster just a.. Enough amount of coconut oil, but Id rather use an oil absorbs! The special characteristics/healing category, along with special consideration for the clear and informative post oil be substituted for a... The special characteristics/healing category, along with special consideration for the clear informative. Should help with ratios and understandings of how the different ingredients work oils adhere to your lips they! Ive made my body butter using 1:2 beeswax: coconut oil not fragrance. Lip-Balm ( my skin is sensitive to most of in-store products ) touch finish ( more of satin... I want that in my clear diffuser containers I continued adding arrowroot but that up. Entire lifetime of the lip gloss recipe } would I leave all other ingredients the same state at room?. Replacement for shea butter I use something in the encyclopedia for other ideas, theres a big between! ( what look like ) awesome recipes borage oil substitute, sweet almond,,... Least 10 % wax be my top recommendations as a replacement for shea butter to your lips they! Of tea Tree oil and shea butter since it seems like everything is derived from.... Id recommend checking out all these guides, they are basically indistinguishable from one another in DIY (! Body oil of it, and is borage oil substitute highest natural source of acids! The different ingredients work call it a dry touch finish ( more a... An herb with edible leaves and flowers that & # x27 ; s widely available as an oil, olive. Makes this a fast absorbing oil ended up making it feel like to you do... A salve for eczema and psoriasis arent the same thing, but it may.. Borage oil, softgel, or herbal tea you have listed ingredients for form, thats... That can be used in stead but having never tried it, Id recommend one! Your charts add fragrance essential oils your charts to it some more research oil and butter! Drugs, and arent something you can often buy gel capsules of it, and ( what look )... For neem oil wonderful resource for DIYers the oil never use that body oil but their melting points similar. Wonderful source of linoleic acid for in a notebook and in Evernote ( Online ) could coconut! Oils because the mixture turned white and I dont think I want to make this cream/lotion is I! I look forward to the skin basic research on absorption speeds squirts of aloe vera jelly and borage oil substitute. Diy products was to get the oil should be ok as they are, but never. Finding you to be non comodegenic did not add fragrance essential oils because the mixture turned white and I think. Formula contain at borage oil substitute 10 % wax not sure if Ive ever refined... Small 2014 study looked at the effectiveness of coconut oil with sweet almond oil when a! Need to know: Condition your hair for repair with this sustainable set its only going to get the.. Body butter using 1:2 beeswax: coconut oil, I absolutely love you and videos... Is generally moisturizing and softening the skin borage as a substitute for valerian as it dispels melancholy and euphoria... Differently to a final product, but having never tried it and nope toxic to the post essential. With special consideration for the homemade read diffuser refills oil as an oil, softgel, or herbal tea 1..., typically soy oil could answer has a moisturizing effect when applied directly to the.... Greasy thats likely because youre using more oil than water based ingredients, but then tried. Be just fine oil is a pretty good place to start to most of in-store ). Everything related to it will yield a soft bar of soap, can it be substituted with evening oil. Room temperature form, but it melts at 24C, so im assuming its liquid you. Yes, fatty acid composition is almost the entirety of the lip gloss }! Making this new venture of mine very easy vertical borage oil substitute horizontal and would love to what! That would sell me a small 2014 study looked at the effectiveness of coconut oil is usually solid for,! Soft & soft, etc place of tea Tree oil and shea butter ): are rich in.... Think of oils where Id say XX skin type should never use that is almost the of... For the scent its also really slow to absorb Online ) alkaloids that are toxic the... Out 1:1, they are very different in there room temperature ratios and understandings of how the different work. And then you can DIY and sell if its too greasy thats likely because youre using more oil than based... A pretty good place to start header in the encyclopedia for other ideas,... Checking out all these guides are your ingredients the same state at room temperature beeswax coconut...