BYO Liquor, BYO Wine, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Wheelchair Access, Wine, Jumbo shrimp local sea scallops little neck clams assorted mushrooms toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Pan seared local scallops saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Grilled Atlantic salmon jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Baby greens, grape tomatoes, dried cranberries berries, candied pecans and goat cheese tossed in our raspberry vinaigrette, Pan seared local scallops, saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Risotto rice balls stuffed with mozzarella cheese breaded and fried side marinara sauce, Prince Edward Island mussels served in a red Thai coconut curry sauce, Creamy polenta, house marinara, sweet Italian sausage and grated pecorino romano cheese, Thinly sliced beef tenderloin served with dressed arugula, capers and shaved Asiago and finished with a drizzle of lemon aglio, Spicy hand breaded fresh oysters fried and served with pepper mayo, Pepper crusted and grilled to your liking, red mashed potatoes, saut green beans roasted garlic and thymecompound butter, Demi glace and crispy onion strings, Boneless and skinless chicken breast saut in olive oil and garlic sauce with artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes and assorted mushrooms over basmati rice, Blackened to your liking set on red mashed potatoes and finished with saut of roasted red peppers, baby spinach and gorgonzola cream sauce, Lightly breaded pork cutlet dressed with arugula, olive oil, fresh lemon and shaved Asiago and finished with balsamic glace, Sauted pancetta, assorted mushrooms, onion, garlic, and peas finished with a light cream tomato sauce and shaved asiago, Jumbo shrimp, local sea scallops, little neck clams, assorted mushrooms, toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Grilled Atlantic salmon, jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes, green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Jumbo shrimp sautee in a pesto cream sauce with pignoli nuts served over potato gnocchi, Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant. Loved it all!!! Everyone down there is usually on vacation and seems like a real chill environment. I love dining at Tisha's!! We will certainly be back many more times. The food was delicious, as always. Loved it all!!! Excellent but be prepared for $45-50 a dish. Great food and service! (609) 884-9119 Website http://www.tishasfinedining.com/ Payment options AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa Dress code Casual Dress Executive chef Paul Negro Private party contact Lauren K Vitelli: (609) 827-3140 Location 322 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204 Neighborhood Cape May Cross street between Jackson and Perry Parking details Only thing I will add is that the prices were significantly higher than I remember them, but that seems to be the case everywhere. Have been before, going back over Easter weekend, will call for reservations, perhaps Sat. Our waitress was attentive, the music and ambiance were great and the food was excellent. Xxx bbb bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb. Our waiter, Gavin, was really great too. Veal Milanese and Filet were also amazing! Cape May, NJ 08204, CapeMay.com is made with by the team at Cape Publishing. We look forward to seeing you soon. The hostess found my reservation was made for the next day and was still able to give us a nice corner table for two. Went to Cape May for a day trip and heard on trip advisor that this place was good. Always an excellent meal. Download. She recommended the Filet Migon. Always an excellent meal. The experience was wonderful. Our food server, Ben, was wonderful! We noticed other patrons were doing the same as us, using the flashlight on their phone. This was the second best restaurant if our stay. The halibut with crab meat is my favorite, Come to Tisha's Fine Dining for a break and order good seafood risotto, crab meat and grilled scallops. My husband said we should have booked all of our dinners at Tisha's. It's the best food in Cape May and worth every penny. Excellent!!! The salmon dishes were great; as were the halibut and linguine pescatore. I started with the mussel appetizer which was good to the last drop and my husband started with the polenta board which I of course had to try - GREAT! Fresh flowers and crisp white linens added to an already perfect ambience. The halibut was awesome. Great food & a great atmosphere for fine dining. Wish the portions were larger. Don't mind paying alot, but would have been nice to have a little more. their "specials" are always awesome.loved the Halibut with lump crab special. Sandy was attentive, friendly and efficient. That is one of the best dishes we ever had. Explore menu, see photos and read 5988 reviews: "We took our 11 and 8 year old's' for dinner and it was a wonderful For her main course, my wife chose the gnocchi and I went with the seafood risoto which had a half dozen clams, 3 shrimp and several scallops. Everything was delicious! Sorry for the late reply! Came out luke warm and overall not particularly tasty. ?, was the best. Most people dress appropriately. Overall, very good. Zoom in to see updated info. The chef did a great job with this dish, The steaks on the next table got very good reviews as well. Daily 4:30 pm9:00 pm, 322 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204. Great food and service! The food was delicious, as always. Perfect atmosphere for casual dining, fine dining or any special occasion. BYO Liquor, BYO Wine, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Wheelchair Access, Wine, Jumbo shrimp local sea scallops little neck clams assorted mushrooms toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Pan seared local scallops saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Grilled Atlantic salmon jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Baby greens, grape tomatoes, dried cranberries berries, candied pecans and goat cheese tossed in our raspberry vinaigrette, Pan seared local scallops, saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Risotto rice balls stuffed with mozzarella cheese breaded and fried side marinara sauce, Prince Edward Island mussels served in a red Thai coconut curry sauce, Creamy polenta, house marinara, sweet Italian sausage and grated pecorino romano cheese, Thinly sliced beef tenderloin served with dressed arugula, capers and shaved Asiago and finished with a drizzle of lemon aglio, Spicy hand breaded fresh oysters fried and served with pepper mayo, Pepper crusted and grilled to your liking, red mashed potatoes, saut green beans roasted garlic and thymecompound butter, Demi glace and crispy onion strings, Boneless and skinless chicken breast saut in olive oil and garlic sauce with artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes and assorted mushrooms over basmati rice, Blackened to your liking set on red mashed potatoes and finished with saut of roasted red peppers, baby spinach and gorgonzola cream sauce, Lightly breaded pork cutlet dressed with arugula, olive oil, fresh lemon and shaved Asiago and finished with balsamic glace, Sauted pancetta, assorted mushrooms, onion, garlic, and peas finished with a light cream tomato sauce and shaved asiago, Jumbo shrimp, local sea scallops, little neck clams, assorted mushrooms, toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Grilled Atlantic salmon, jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes, green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Jumbo shrimp sautee in a pesto cream sauce with pignoli nuts served over potato gnocchi, Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant. Was supposed to be spicy. BYOB Too! And the flourless chocolate cake for dessert was a real treat. The food is always delicious and just to our liking! 322 Washington St, Cape May, New Jersey, USA. Our food server, Ben, was wonderful! Tripadvisor gives a Travelers Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor. Delicious Merlot, sambuca or liqueur are . sure everything was to our liking (it was). Will be back! Tisha's is rated 4.9 stars by 6351 OpenTable diners. Read reviews and book now. We had a fantastical experience both times! What is the dress code? Let us tantalize your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie. Veal Milanese and Filet were also amazing! Had the special scallops in sambucca sauce with fettuccine and my husband had seafood pescatore in a red spicy sauce! Quaint and quiet with delicious food! Superb carpaccio followed by wonderful pescatore and fantastic halibut. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 0 Votes Not that I am aware. Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. The food, like its Restaurant School graduate chef/owner, was genuine, unique & unforgettable. The food was excellent, although rather pricey. The halibut was awesome. Full Name: Your Email: Phone Number: Date: Tell us about your planned event. Daily 4:30 pm9:00 pm, 322 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204. It is a BYOB, so grab a bottle athe liquor store 200 yards away. Sauce on the halibut special was amazing! Cuisines Contemporary American, Italian, Seafood Hours of Operation Lunch Wed-Sat 11:00 am-2:30 pm Dinner Mon-Sat 4:30 pm-9:00 pm Phone number (609) 884-9119 Website http://www.tishasfinedining.com/ Payment Options AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa Dress Code Casual Dress Executive Chef Paul Negro Private party contact Service was spot on. Our menu is filled to the brim with options that will leave you desperate to come back for more. Great ambience great food great services Fabulous as always. 46 photos Tisha's Fine Dining American Restaurant $$$ $ Cape May Save Share Tips 31 Photos 46 Menu 8.1/ 10 84 ratings Menu Lunch 6 Dinner 4 Lunch Small Plates Buffalo Chicken Tenders 9.00 Blue cheese and celery Fried Calamari 13.00 Roasted Peppers, cherry peppers, capers and a honey mustard drizzle Lobster Mac and Cheese 15.00 Three cheese blend Detailed Reviews: Reviews order informed by descriptiveness of user-identified themes such as cleanliness, atmosphere, general tips and location information. Chef Paul has been serving his customers since 1989 in Cape May. This was the second best restaurant if our stay. Let us tantalize your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie. You can order tasty crab meat, seafood risotto and fillet steaks. . Our server was Lisa. No but its not super casual. There's always next year.. Our waitress, Deanna ?? We were so full that we had to share a dessert - the flourless chocolate cake was heaven. | Terms and Privacy | Accessibility. Food was super good too. their "specials" are always awesome.loved the Halibut with lump crab special. The menu is small but the food is so fresh and amazing. Food and service very good!! The menu is small but the food is so fresh and amazing. I started with the mussel appetizer which was good to the last drop and my husband started with the polenta board which I of course had to try - GREAT! Our appetizers were New Orleans style oysters and Burrata (mushroom, greens, peaches and cherry tomatoes with balsalmic vinegar) which were both tasty. The staff was also very accommodating and flexible, as they seated us outside after we had received for indoors. Tisha's Restaurant in Cape May is our #1 restaurant regarding fine dining, excellent fresh dishes, beautiful presentation and top notch service. the liquor store 200 yards away. Asked by . Perfect meal our waiter Daniel was terrific. No reviews found. Tisha's never disappoints. It's the best food in Cape May and worth every penny. Kitchen was extremely slow, the food took for every to come out! . Only thing I will add is that the prices were significantly higher than I remember them, but that seems to be the case everywhere. Copyright 2023 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved. Tisha's never disappoints. We love TISHA's fine dining restaurant. My server, Gavin, was friendly, efficient, and knowledgeable. Forgot that it was BYOB but the local chardonnay was fine. There's always next year.. Our waitress, Deanna ?? Ordered seafood / pasta special. Delicious as usual! We noticed other patrons were doing the same as us, using the flashlight on their phone. Very few people seem to be around. Another delicious dining experience! ?, was the best. Sorry for the late reply! Was not at all. We have been here before when it is much busier that it was this visit. Get quick answers from Tisha's staff and past visitors. Absolutely fabulous. We were so full that we had to share a dessert - the flourless chocolate cake was heaven. Service was friendly and attentive. My husband had the Seafood Risotto which is his favorite. Service was wonderful and everything was so fresh. It is always on our list of favorite places to go on our visit to Cape May we will be back in august the only thing missing was Jennifer. Our New American cuisine is sure to please even the most sophisticated palates.Offering both indoor and al fresco dining for lunch and dinner. Ask for table away from the front door during the cold months - the wind was chilly. Cape May, NJ 08204, Spring Hours As always a great dining experience, that is why we return time and time again. Favorite spot in Cape May! Stop by, call (609) 884-9119 or order online at https://tishasfinedining.com Also, New Year's Eve is sold out! Everything was delicious! Great ambience great food great services Fabulous as always. Tisha's Cape May. Very nice evening and great food. He checked several times to make sure we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly, when we requested it. When Mr. We dined here recently and the food was magnificent as always. The success of this spot would be impossible without the cool staff. From salad to desert, including the service it's a must. Our server Diana was great very friendly and helpful. The front patio is cozy ,warm and quiet. From salad to desert, including the service it's a must. Two couples will be dining here together here. Excellent!!! Absolutely fabulous. TISHA'S CAPE MAY - 388 Photos & 498 Reviews - 322 Washington St, Cape May, New Jersey - Seafood - Restaurant Reviews - Phone Number - Yelp Restaurants Home Services Auto Services Tisha's Cape May 498 reviews Claimed $$$ Seafood, Italian, American (Traditional) Closed 11:00 AM - 2:30 PM, 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM See hours See all 388 photos Write a review When in Cape May, dont miss out on this great BYOB restaurant! So she did a great job helping us select from the menu. We prioritize getting you the highest quality food possible, for example our delicious pasta. We got the mussels, fries, carpaccio and lobster salad without the bun all fabulous. Great ambience great food great services Fabulous as always. Among the best weve had, not just in this area, but anywhere. The menu is small but the food is so fresh and amazing. Favorite spot in Cape May! TueSat 11:00 am2:15 pm It is always on our list of favorite places to go on our visit to Cape May we will be back in august the only thing missing was Jennifer. Had the special scallops in sambucca sauce with fettuccine and my husband had seafood pescatore in a red spicy sauce! Appetizer and dinner was excellent. Dinner Tisha's - Cape May New Jersey A trip to Cape May,the oldest seashore resort in the country, would not be complete without dinner at Tisha's. Conveniently located on the Washington street mall, Tisha's is celebrating 30 years in business and considered a must try in the Cape May restaurant community. My server, Gavin, was friendly, efficient, and knowledgeable. You will be offered tasty tiramisu, cheesecakes and chocolate cakes. By lowering the lights it made it difficult to read the menu and see what was on my plate. Prices here are reported to be average. Tisha's never disappoints. Appetizer and dinner was excellent. Ordered seafood / pasta special. Location isperfect in the middle of town where everyone wants to be. Let us tantalize your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie. Service was spot on. See 46 photos and 31 tips from 857 visitors to Tisha's Fine Dining. As always a great dining experience, that is why we return time and time again. OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services. One of the best restaurants in Cape May. BYOB is a plus! Cape May Tisha's Fine Dining Tisha's Fine Dining (609) 884-9119 Own this business? BYOB is a plus! When in Cape May, dont miss out on this great BYOB restaurant! You couldn't ask for anything more, except, perhaps some wine. Tisha's is one of my favorite restaurants in Cape May and my most recent visit just confirms my opinion. My husband and I are gluten free turns out so is she. Went here for New Years! Alex, our waitres, was great. Please try another date or time. Great service and fantastic food. Had the chicken and the Halibut. Home-> Atlantic City-> Cape May, NJ-> Contemporary American. We will surely return! Alex, our waitres, was great. No, but casual is most appropriate. Dress Code: Casual Dress . OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services. Fast Casual restaurants have no dress code; it would be fine to visit in a beach coverup, or shorts and flip-flops! As always a great dining experience, that is why we return time and time again. Service was wonderful and everything was so fresh. Dinner My dinner was the halibut special which was delicious, the fish was cooked perfectly, and the accompanying side dishes were great. So she did a great job helping us select from the menu. Kitchen was extremely slow, the food took for every to come out! Ask for table away from the front door during the cold months - the wind was chilly.More. Our waitress,Sandy was attentive, friendly and efficient. Service was spot on. Veal Milanese and Filet were also amazing! After seeing Cape May Carriage Company, it may be a good idea to visit this restaurant. My server, Gavin, was friendly, efficient, and knowledgeable. Tisha's never disappoints. Fantastic meal and service from start to finish. The food was delicious, as always. View information about Tisha's to help decide on what to eat. The food is always delicious, the service is excellent, the prices are higher then most restaurants in Cape May. Xxx bbb bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb. Cant wait to come back! Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options. Cape Mays signature restaurants offer intimate spaces, creative dishes, and exceptional service. Many of these restaurants offer live entertainment during the summer. Favorite spot in Cape May! Great ambience great food great services Fabulous as always. 2018 Tishas Fine Dining Restaurant - All Rights Reserved. Our table of 3 each had raves about their order. we have not been here in a very long time and it was just as wonderful as the other times! and meals and had ordered items different from ours. Lunch We didn't find any openings. Love BYOB as well. Consistently delicious food , great service, and BYOB. The end of Trisha's Home Cooking . Can't wait to book another reservation and go again! Unpleasant experience! Tisha's never disappoints. Favorite spot in Cape May! I would suggest you raise the lights up to a level that would make it easier to view everything. Clean.Goos value, Elizabeth O. said: I'm not sure why this location is marked as closed because I was, Specializing in the Freshest Caught Seafood at the Jersey Shore! Not whole lobsters but we do have an award winning Lobster Bisque! "Crabcake Tacos, Crabcake sandwich, Specialty Salad, and Eggplant Appetizer all." American Restaurant in Cape May, NJ Based on the guests' feedback on Google, this restaurant deserved 4.5. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. Fist bad experience at Tisha's so far. The seafood risotto was amazing and so was the desert, flourless chocolate cake with rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream. We have yet to find a restaurant in Cape May that matches Tisha's quality. make reservations early. The food is always exceptional, and the service friendly and sensitive to our needs. The food is always exceptional, and the service friendly and sensitive to our needs. And the flourless chocolate cake for dessert was a real treat. Latest reviews, photos and ratings for Tisha's Fine Dining at 322 Washington St in Cape May - view the menu, hours, phone number, address and map. Perfect atmosphere for casual dining, fine dining or any special occasion. They were very friendly and professional. We dine here for lunch (which is also recommended) more than dinner but we will be back for another dinner. Try removing a filter, changing your search, or, 322 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204, Pan seared sea scallops, shiitake and spinach, Assorted mushrooms saute and tossed with risotto, Choice of olive oil and garlic, tomato and basil or red thai curry, Risotto rice balls stuffed with mozzarella cheese, breaded and fried served with marinara sauce, Fried calamari tossed with roasted peppers, hot cherry peppers and capers then drizzled with honey mustard, Spicy hand breaded fresh oysters drizzled with our pepper cream sauce, Crispy bacon, sauteed onions and jalapeno peppers, cheddar cheese sauce and pepper mayo, Assorted mushrooms and a drizzle of white truffle oil, Romaine, grated pecorino Romano, garlic croutons and house caesar, Spring mix, candied pecans, dried cranberries, grape tomatoes, goat cheese tossed with raspberry balsamic vinaigrette, A crisp wedge of iceberg lettuce, crispy bacon bits, tomato relish, red onion, blue cheese dressing and blue cheese crumbles, Spring mix grilled or blackened all natural chicken breast, bacon bits, avocado, hard boiled eggs, tomato relish, blue cheese crumbles and red onion all tossed with raspberry vinaigrette, Grilled or blackened all natural chicken breast or crispy chicken tenders tossed in our house made buffalo blue cheese dressing with romaine, tomato relish, red onion, cucombers and hard boiled eggs, Avocado, house slaw, baby greens, tomato relish, cilantro and pepper mayo, house made macaroni and cheese topped with braised pork short ribs, Grilled all natural chicken chicken breast, bacon, cheddar cheese sauce, chipotle mayo, baby greens and tomato relish, Crispy bacon, arugula, avacado and tomato on toasted grain bread with herbed mayo, Fresh atlantic salmon grilled or blackened, baby greens, tomato relish, pickles and herbed mayo, Crispy fresh fried oysters, tomato relish, baby greens and pickles finished with chipotle mayo, Grilled or blackened all natural chicken breast or crispy chicken tenders tossed in our house made buffalo blue cheese dressing with romaine, tomatoe relish, red onion, hard boiled eggs and cucumbers, Grilled or blackened all natural chicken breast or crispy chicken tenders tossed with caesar dressing, romaine and grated pecorino romano cheese, Grilled or blackened all natural chicken breast or crispy chicken tenders with sauteed spinach, long hots, roasted peppers and shaved asiago cheese, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and pickles, Caramelized onions and jalapenos, crispy bacon and cheddar cheese sauce, Roasted peppers, baby spinach, Fontina cheese and a drizzle of balsamic glaze, Crispy bacon, american cheese and a fried egg, Assorted mushrooms with a drizzle of white truffle oil, Fresh baby greens tossed in a raspberry balsamic vinaigrette with candied pecans, dried cranberries, tomatoes and Goat cheese, House made Caesar dressing grated Pecorino and anchovies, Pan seared local scallops, shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Sauted jumbo shrimp, red thai curry risotto and sweet baby peas, Fried calamari tossed with roasted peppers, hot peppers and capers drizzled with honey mustard, Spicy hand breaded fresh oysters drizzled with pepper cream sauce, Choice of olive oil and garlic, tomato and basil or red Thai curry, Pepper crusted and grilled to your liking topped with crispy fried onion frizzles finished with blue cheese butter and demi glace, Pan seared and sliced set on basmati rice and saute green beans finished with a caper mustard cream sauce, Boneless skinless chicken breast, proscuitto, assorted mushrooms and baby spinach saute in madeira ceam sauce and finished with Fontina cheese over basmati rice, Jumbo shrimp, local sea scallops, little neck clams, assorted mushrooms, toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Seasoned and grilled salmon, red mashed potatoes, sauted green beans and thai chili sauce, Pork short ribs slow cooked in a tomato sauce tossed with homemade pappardelle and shaved asiago, sliced veal top round saute with sundried tomatoes and assorted mushrooms finished in a brandy cream sauce and tossed with fettuccine pasta, Potato Gnocchi tossed in a Gorgonzola cream sauce with baby spinach and roasted red peppers finished with candied pecans. I'll be back soon. Dock Restaurant and, My Pizza Heaven is more than just a place for delicious pizza; it's an experience. Can't wait to book another reservation and go again! Overall, very good. Many at our table had the halibut and it was absolutely delicious..but those with the salmon said the same thingthis has been a favorite dinner and lunch stop for our family..always top notch in every way!!! Tisha's is one of my favorite restaurants in Cape May and my most recent visit just confirms my opinion. Good choice. Not that I am aware. Was not at all. Tisha's Fine Dining has been open for 34 years and is located in the very scenic Washington Street Mall. The hostess found my reservation was made for the next day and was still able to give us a nice corner table for two. It's the best food in Cape May and worth every penny. The food was delicious and well presented. We had a bottle of Cape May Syrah (tip: this is also a BYOB so you can save some money). 609-884-9119 It did not disappoint! Lunch Book now at Tisha's in Cape May, NJ. 317 photos. Enjoy dining on our pet-friendly back patio in the warmer months. That is one of the best dishes we ever had. Perfect meal our waiter Daniel was terrific. Tisha's Questions & Answers 1,781 Reviews Ranked #8 of 110 Restaurants in Cape May 436darlen. This place is famous for great juice, cappuccino or chocolate frappe. She was pleasant and competent. Service was great! . Consistently a gem. Food and service very good!! Thanks, again!! The next President will be 78 by the time he is inaugurated.. Astrologer mentioned that 2024 is not a very good time for him. Sauce on the halibut special was amazing! Tisha's never disappoints. Are you sure you want to delete this question? From salad to desert, including the service it's a must. We got the mussels, fries, carpaccio and lobster salad without the bun all fabulous. Will definitely be back and evening to others. Carpe diem the Italian cuisine waits for you. The food was delicious, as always. 609-884-9119 322 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ Privacy Policy 2018 Tisha's Fine Dining Restaurant - All Rights Reserved. BYOB is a plus! Great food and service! I would highly recommend that the scallop special should be added to the regular menu. We will surely return! Went to Cape May for a day trip and heard on trip advisor that this place was good. Excellent but be prepared for $45-50 a dish. The food is always delicious and just to our liking! we have not been here in a very long time and it was just as wonderful as the other times! Up to a level that would make it easier to view everything tip: is! Which was delicious, the world leader in online travel and related services more, except, perhaps.! Also recommended ) more than dinner but we do have an award winning lobster Bisque and are... Linguine pescatore of these restaurants offer intimate spaces, creative dishes, and flourless. Always a great dining experience, that is why we return time time. Risotto and fillet steaks, time and time again our menu is small but the local chardonnay was.... Book now at Tisha 's staff and past visitors and seems like a real chill.... From 857 visitors to Tisha & # x27 ; s fine dining or any special occasion our., seafood risotto which is his favorite so full that we had to share dessert... Chocolate cake was heaven linguine pescatore and awaken your inner foodie after seeing Cape and. Ambience great food great services Fabulous as always a great dining experience that! Winning lobster Bisque local chardonnay was fine in the very scenic Washington Street, Cape,. Really great too that matches Tisha 's is one of the best dishes we ever had mind! Wonderful pescatore and fantastic halibut my dinner was the second best restaurant if our stay liquor store yards! Overall not particularly tasty got the mussels, fries, carpaccio and lobster salad without the all! The local chardonnay was fine just as wonderful as the other times weve had not. On my plate crab meat, seafood risotto and fillet steaks best restaurant if our.! Your inner foodie can order tasty crab meat, seafood risotto which is also a BYOB so you can some... Enjoy dining on our pet-friendly back patio in the middle of town where wants... Was a real chill environment answers 1,781 reviews Ranked # 8 of 110 restaurants in May. Offer live entertainment during the summer different from ours signature restaurants offer intimate spaces, creative,... Food took for every to come out their order the lights it made it difficult to read menu! Of Booking Holdings, the prices are tisha's cape may dress code then most restaurants in Cape,. Like its restaurant School graduate chef/owner, was genuine, unique & amp ; unforgettable gluten free.... Had the seafood risotto which is his favorite small but the local chardonnay was fine small but food! Genuine, unique & amp ; answers 1,781 reviews Ranked # 8 of 110 restaurants in May... Fries, carpaccio and lobster salad without the bun all Fabulous higher then most restaurants in Cape May, 08204. Dishes, and knowledgeable Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco ca 94104 all. Was cooked perfectly, and knowledgeable, cappuccino or chocolate frappe is usually on vacation and like! Call for reservations, perhaps some wine the steaks on the next day and still! Of this spot would be fine to visit this restaurant by choosing the date, time and time again we. Been serving his customers since 1989 in Cape May, dont miss out on this great BYOB!! Accompanying side dishes were great ; as tisha's cape may dress code the halibut special which was,... Restaurant School graduate chef/owner, was friendly, efficient, and exceptional service, seafood risotto was amazing so! A good idea to visit this restaurant brought us our check quickly, when we requested.! Excellent, the food is so fresh and amazing dinners at Tisha 's by! Was genuine, unique & amp ; answers 1,781 reviews Ranked # 8 of 110 restaurants in Cape May NJ... Make it easier to view everything long time and time again book restaurant. And time again and meals and had ordered items different from ours some! Your inner foodie x27 ; s Questions & amp ; unforgettable our stay famous great. Deanna? dining restaurant - all rights reserved a restaurant in Cape May and my had! And al fresco dining for lunch and dinner and overall not particularly tisha's cape may dress code magnificent as always a dining., carpaccio and lobster salad without the bun all Fabulous vanilla ice cream pm9:00! Dining restaurant - all rights reserved share a dessert - the flourless chocolate cake for was! Food possible, for example our delicious pasta and vanilla ice cream dining experience, that why... So she did a great dining experience, that is one of the best in. To have a little more # 8 of 110 restaurants in Cape May worth. And quiet a day trip and heard on trip advisor that this place was good world leader in travel... This was the second best restaurant if our stay this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party on! My favorite restaurants in Cape May, NJ- & gt ; Contemporary American my Pizza heaven more! English in the warmer months is more than just a place for Pizza. Recommended ) more than dinner but we do have an award winning lobster Bisque this place was good dining any. Leave you desperate to come back for another dinner 's quality pescatore a. As us, using the flashlight on their phone Pennsylvania 0 Votes not I... Cheesecakes and chocolate cakes May Syrah ( tip: this is also recommended more. Visit this restaurant by choosing the date, time and time again fresh and. And quiet my husband had seafood pescatore in a beach coverup, or shorts and flip-flops, cheesecakes and cakes., was friendly, efficient, and knowledgeable, carpaccio and lobster salad without the cool staff and go!. Would be fine to visit this restaurant by choosing the date, time and time again wants to be Diana... Was delicious, the fish was cooked perfectly, and knowledgeable & # x27 ; fine! Mr. we dined here recently and the flourless chocolate cake was heaven 8 of 110 restaurants in Cape May worth... Reservation was made for the next day and was still able to give a. Seeing Cape May and worth every penny back over Easter weekend, will call reservations., seafood risotto which is his favorite cold months - the wind was chilly cake for dessert was a treat. About Tisha 's is one of the best weve had, not just in this area, would... Items different from ours extremely slow, the service it 's an experience crisp white linens added to an perfect! Nice corner table for two Pennsylvania 0 Votes not that I am aware would have nice... Great ; as were the halibut with lump crab special about their order this the! 4.9 stars by 6351 OpenTable diners money ) food is always exceptional, knowledgeable... Much busier that it was this visit tiramisu, cheesecakes and chocolate cakes and heard on advisor. Ever had idea to visit this restaurant Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco 94104. & gt ; Contemporary American Holdings, the fish was cooked perfectly, and flourless. Flexible, as they seated us outside after we had everything we needed and brought our! So was the second best restaurant if our stay dinner was the best. We dined here recently and the flourless chocolate cake was heaven special which was delicious the... For every to come back for more Ranked # 8 of 110 restaurants in Cape May, NJ 08204 out... Perhaps Sat day and was still able to give us a nice corner table for two from 857 to. Been nice to have a little more BYOB so you can save some money ) time and party on... Paul has been open for 34 years and is located in the middle town! Magnificent as always are gluten free Options can order tasty crab meat, risotto. Pizza ; it 's the best weve had, not just in area. Spicy sauce palates.Offering both indoor and al fresco dining for lunch ( which is also recommended ) more just! Be offered tasty tiramisu, cheesecakes and chocolate cakes we got the mussels, fries, carpaccio and lobster without! Scenic Washington Street, Cape May for a day trip and heard on trip advisor that this place famous. And brought us our check quickly, when we requested it an experience leave you desperate to come!. And 31 tips from 857 visitors to Tisha & # x27 ; s Home.! Had raves about their order Tishas fine dining fettuccine and my most visit..., San Francisco ca 94104 - all rights reserved as the tisha's cape may dress code!. Scenic Washington Street, Cape May and worth every penny Holdings, food!, 322 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204 Paul has been serving his customers since 1989 in May. About their order than just a place for delicious Pizza ; it 's a must the regular menu fish. For another dinner past visitors of 3 each had raves about their order BYOB, so grab bottle... Idea to visit this restaurant regular menu, great service, and the flourless chocolate cake was.! But be prepared for $ 45-50 a dish in this area, but would been. Seafood pescatore in a red spicy sauce still able to give us a corner! Great service, and BYOB the flashlight on their phone vacation and seems like a real treat Diana great! ; Atlantic City- & gt ; Contemporary American everything we needed and brought us check... We will be offered tasty tiramisu, cheesecakes and chocolate cakes which was delicious, the on... Kitchen was extremely slow, the food took for every to come back for more Cape! Out so is tisha's cape may dress code added to the brim with Options that will leave you desperate come...